loading

How to Compare Insurance Company Rankings

Insurance company ranking chart

When you're looking to sign up for insurance or review an existing policy, one of the first questions that pops into your head is about insurance company rankings. It's natural to feel that bigger companies are safer, and a higher rank suggests they're more trustworthy. However, rankings change completely depending on the criteria used, so it's crucial to know what metric you're looking at first.

In this post, we'll walk you through how to look at insurance company rankings based on different criteria, how to check life insurance and non-life insurance separately, and the proper steps to connect that ranking information to your actual purchasing decisions. If you're looking for rankings in a specific area, like auto insurance or life insurance, you can follow this same process.

What Criteria Should You Use When Checking Insurance Company Rankings?

Insurance company rankings are typically measured by size indicators like total revenue, total assets, or gross written premiums. These metrics only tell you how large the company is; they don't directly tell you if their coverage is good or if they pay out claims efficiently. Therefore, if you look at rankings, you must first check what specific metric is being used.

  • Revenue-Based Ranking: This shows the total amount of profit the company generated over the course of a year.
  • Total Assets Ranking: This reflects the overall scale of the funds the company has accumulated and manages from premiums paid by customers. This is often used when looking at life insurance companies.
  • Financial Soundness Indicators: Metrics like the solvency ratio show how capable the company actually is of paying out claims.

If you're in the process of buying insurance, it's more helpful to look at financial soundness indicators alongside the size rankings. Even if a company is large, you need to check its indicators if they are low at a specific point in time. Conversely, a company of moderate size might be worth considering if its indicators are stable.

Life Insurance vs. Property & Casualty Insurance: Why You Need to Separate Them

Insurance companies generally fall into two main categories: life insurance companies and property & casualty (P&C) insurers. Life insurance companies cover things related to your life, like survival, death, or illness. P&C insurers cover losses that happen, such as car accidents, fires, or travel mishaps. Because of this difference, mixing the rankings of these two industries together just muddies the water.

CategoryKey Ranking Metrics to Look AtWhat You Should Check as a Policyholder
Life Insurance CompaniesTotal Assets, Revenue, Solvency RatioCoverage details for whole life, health, and annuity products, plus surrender value terms
P&C InsurersGross Written Premium, Revenue, Solvency RatioCoverage scope and claim conditions for auto, fire, and travel insurance

If you're looking at rankings for auto insurance, you need to look within the P&C insurers and check both their premium levels and how they handle claims. If you're looking at life insurance rankings, it's smart to look at their total assets alongside the structure of their products.

How to Use Rankings to Make an Informed Insurance Decision

Instead of letting the rankings dictate your decision, it's more practical to use them as a reference point and narrow down your options by following these steps.

  1. First, define your goal for the insurance. Whether you need coverage for illness, accidents, or retirement planning will tell you which industry to focus on.
  2. Check the size rankings and financial health indicators for that specific industry.
  3. Select two or three companies from the top ranks and compare their premiums and coverage under identical terms.
  4. Thoroughly review the policy documents to check for excluded coverage, claim payout conditions, and surrender value terms.

Using comparison tools on insurance websites during this process can make it easy to view several companies at once. However, keep in mind that different sites might compare different items or use different standards, so it's safest to ensure you are comparing apples to apples.

What to Watch Out For When Using an Insurance Agent

If you're having trouble choosing a company based on rankings alone, consulting with an insurance agent is another option. While agents can compare products from various companies, the information they give you might change depending on their affiliated company or the specific products they sell. When looking for a recommended insurance agent, here are a few things you should check:

  • Verify their affiliation and whether they are properly registered.
  • See if they explain their recommendations based on coverage limits and premiums.
  • Confirm that you can get and read the product disclosure documents and policy terms yourself.
  • If they suggest canceling your current policy to sign a new one, first examine the surrender value and how the coverage changes during any gap period.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I judge car insurance company rankings based on premiums?

Premiums are an important factor, but a lower premium doesn't automatically mean better claims handling. It's best to compare premiums for the exact same coverage and also get information on the claims filing and payout process.

Does a large total asset size in life insurance company rankings guarantee safety?

Total assets only show the company's size. To check its actual ability to pay claims, you need to look at financial health indicators like the solvency ratio.

Insurance company rankings change often; what date should I use as a reference?

Rankings fluctuate depending on when they were compiled. It's most accurate to check the official disclosure date and look at data from right before you plan to sign up.

Insurance company rankings are just a starting point; your final decision must align with your coverage needs and goals. If you're planning to sign up soon or are looking to wrap up an existing policy, I recommend writing down your coverage needs today and comparing two or three top-ranked companies under the exact same terms.